Christopher Katongo is better than Lionel Messi

Christopher Katongo is better than Lionel Messi. Messi is the best player in the world, that is undeniable, but he isn’t entertaining to watch any more, his zig-zag, mechanical runs are inevitable, functional and boring. One of the players better to watch than him is, of course, Christopher Katongo, Zambia’s fiery and lively captain and talisman in their Cup of Nations triumph, the official Player of the Tournament. Excitement-wise, Messi is Uncle Ben’s basmati rice while Katongo is Tilda basmati rice with a bottle of Supermalt. But even when you analyse the core of them as footballing men, Katongo is clearly the better footballer:

Military Roughness

Football is no stranger to military analogies – box to box midfielders have become known as ‘midfield generals’, full-backs ‘bomb forward’, the pitch is described as a ‘battlefield’, the Germany national team is much-revered for its ‘military-like efficiency’ and one of their greatest players – Gerd Muller – was nicknamed ‘Der Bomber’. Yet very few players actually possess this romanticised military background.

Katongo is one of the few who does, being a soldier since 2001 when he joined Zambia army club Green Buffaloes. Naturally, Katongo is a one-man army, the mere appearance of him relentless and overwhelming, a 29-year-old, constantly simmering pan of boiling blood as he surges through attacking areas with the vigour of capitalist society commuter who is late to work. It was no surprise, then, that he was promoted to Warrant Officer Class One in the Zambia army by Zambia’s President during the tournament for his skill and exceptional leadership skills.  Katongo is the type of player who could play for any team in the world and not look out of place. Even Barcelona. After all, Ludovic Giuly didn’t look out of place in a Barca team including Messi, Ronaldinho and Samuel Eto’o and I like to think of Katongo as Zambia’s answer to Ludovic Giuly. But better.

He has that look

It’s that look. The best athletes – the Roger Federers, Michael Jordans, Usain Bolts of this world – have that look, the look of tunnelled focus in pursuit of victory. Katongo has that look, Messi doesn’t have that look. You know that look that I’m talking about. Katongo had a fiery, clenched face and an intense, strong-willed stare whenever we saw him pull on the Chipolopolo jersey at the Cup of Nations. It’s only now that I realise what the look was about – he was visualising the moment he’d lift the Cup of Nations, a vacant, focused stare into the swagger of victory.

If that isn’t enough, a bright white armband tightens around his left arm which complements his bright white boots – which you can’t miss as they dot around the field. Katongo simply stands out from the crowd, even if you don’t want to know him, you will. Messi, meanwhile, has standard South-American hair which, whilst being perfectly lovely, just about every South American playmaker or attacking player has had over the history of football.  I could try and look like Katongo and copy his style and swagger but I can’t. You either have that look or you don’t.

Petty-Thief Theory

That look I speak of adds to the Katongo Petty-Thief Theory. There are some footballers who shouldn’t be playing at the highest level at all – they are thieves, they’re not earning a living, they’re stealing a living instead. Katongo has something resembling a petty thief you’ll find in a Lagos slum – this raw, swirling streetwise appeal apparent in his razor-sharp shape up, an appeal that his football career, which has taken him to foreign lands, has been unable to refine. Cruelly, for example, it was actually the dazzling left-winger Rainford Kalaba who deserved to win the 2012 Cup of Nations player of the tournament – many who watched the Cup of Nations would agree with that statement – yet you couldn’t ignore Katongo, despite the way he faded in the knockout stages you knew that without his leadership Zambia wouldn’t have won the Cup of Nations.


The moment when you score a goal is the opportunity to release all your frustration or taunt the opposition. For some players, there a few things better than scoring away from home and knowing that they are responsible for the silence that dominates the stadium. Against co-hosts Equatorial Guinea Katongo scored the winner and then choreographed a celebration which told the crowd to hush (but in a polite manner, with a sumptuous dance to go with it) – a celebration that reduced the atmosphere in the Estadio de Bata stadium more joyless than that of a coffin. It was a celebration Katongo choreographed throughout the tournament and my personal favourite. Messi doesn’t celebrate like that, even when he scores a late winner against Real Madrid.

He is a footballer’s footballer

“What is a ‘footballer’s footballer’?” You ask.  Eamon Dunphy coined the term in his thought-provoking account of his troubled season at Millwall in the 1970s in his book Only a Game?:

“I believe the good pro was the true hero of professional sport…The good pro is a trier…The good pro accepts responsibility – both his and when the going gets tough, yours…He is woven into the fabric of every good side and every great side too…In attack or defence, at home or away, in January mud, April wind or August sunshine, every game is a test and there are so many ways to cheat, to walk away from your responsibility to the team. The good pro never does. He is sometimes knackered, often in despair but never out of the ball game, never on the missing list…He is the footballer’s footballer.”

Near the end of last season, Messi was left on the bench for a La Liga fixture because Pep Guardiola wanted to rest him for a midweek Champions League clash. The Argentine refused to train the next day, absent from training, angry that it meant he wouldn’t be able to eclipse Cristiano Ronaldo in the goalscoring stakes. Christopher Katongo is the footballer’s footballer;  he doesn’t do strops and he always arrives early for training. When things weren’t going well at the Cup of Nations, like in the soggy, splashing conditions against Libya when Zambia went twice behind or the relentless pressure they had to endure from Ghana in the first half of the semi-final, young Nathan Sinkala or any other team-mate of Katongo’s only needed to have a look at Katongo’s feral intensity to know that they would get through this and everything was going to be alright.

5 Comments on Christopher Katongo is better than Lionel Messi

  1. That was interesting, but allow me to leave some notes:

    1. Maybe we are too used to his brilliance, but Messi is never boring to watch. Not to me, at least.
    2. You can’t judge footballers by how the look, or dance! 😀
    Although I think Messi has ‘that’ look.
    3. I am surprised you didn’t mention Messi’s not-so-good performance with Argentina, which makes him less of a perfect player – if there is such thing, and actually puts the comparison in favour of Katongo.

    Finally: Last paragraph, first line, it’s Pep, or Josep, not Pepe :]

  2. Awesome article ! ! !
    Absolutely brilliant ! !

  3. WOW…
    The most bizarre exaggerating ridiculous title ever…don’t compare anyone to Messi please for your own good, cause you will sound unrealistic, especially if the other player plays for Zambia!…Katongo is great, but Messi!!! come on

  4. Hahaha…apologies to the writer, I just looked at the title and didn’t see the rest of the story…hilarious…sorry again for the criticism…what can I do, Messi is may all-time favorite

  5. You arre so awesome! I do not suppose I’ve read through anything like this
    before. So good to find another perseon with a few unique thoughts on this issue.

    Seriously.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something tht is needed on the internet, someone with
    a bit of originality!

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. SFG Scout Report: Emmanuel Mayuka « sandalsforgoalposts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: